The Taliban “Split”: Forking a Knife
22 Nov, 2001 · 643
Suba Chandran is skeptical about a possible split in the Taliban
One major war effort of the West and the
Northern Alliance
inside
Afghanistan
was to split the Taliban. The West, led by the
US
, has been using at least three strategies to achieve this.
Pakistan
and National Alliance, along with some other Afghan leaders have been engaged in splitting the Taliban ever since the war began. One of the main missions of Abdul Haq, a former mujahideen who went inside
Afghanistan
towards the end of October, was to contact leaders within the Taliban who could be won over. Unfortunately, but expectedly he was killed by the Taliban.
Afghanistan
, it is doubtful whether it had any significant impact inside as the Talibs hardly watch these programmes.
Kabul
. Mullah Hasan, the acting head of the Council (who replaced Mullah Rabbani after his death), Mulla Wakil Ahmad Mutawwakil, Taliban’s Foreign Minister, and 25-30 others form this Kandhahar group.
Pakistan
. When Mullah Omar formed the Taliban, young Afghans of the Afghan refugee community in
Pakistan
found a purpose to their life by joining the Taliban. Their exact strength is not known, though it is estimated around 30,000.
Pakistan
’s Inter Intelligence Service (ISI) to fight the Soviet troops, they had enough firepower to prevent the then ruling Rabbani government from having any influence inside their territory. When the Taliban movement gained momentum in 1994-95, the first casualty was these warlords. They did not endorse Omar’s fundamentalist policies, but had no option but to join the Taliban for survival.
Afghanistan
before and after the Soviet troops left
Afghanistan
. At present, they have approximately 5000 Arab fighters alongside the Taliban.
First, the intense bombing to cripple the Taliban militarily and terrorize the Taliban fighters into abandoning the Taliban.
The second strategy employs diplomatic and financial means to engender the split. The US,
The third strategy involves the use ofthe electronic media, led by the CNN, to create the impression that the Taliban is splitting. Though this propaganda has been successful outside
What is the liklihood of a split? It is essential to examine the composition of the Taliban to study the probabilities of a split.
The Taliban comprises five major groups. First a core led by Mullah Omar, also known as the Kandhahar group. This is a small group comprising those who had joined Mullah Omar before the Taliban emerged and belonged to the Supreme Council that ruled from
The second group consists of the Talibs, or students, who are followers of Mullah Omar. The Talibs are young Pashtun Afghans educated in various madrassas in
The third group consists of former warlords and their supporters who joined the Taliban either voluntarily or out of fear. These warlords, belong to various communities, are predominantly former mujahideens, and held small territories under their control. With weapons supplied by the CIA and
The fourth group comprises of mujahideens who were part of the then ruling Rabbani government and later defected to the Taliban.
The fifth group is made up of Arabs who came with Osama bin Laden to
Of these five groups, the first – the Kandhahar group – remains loyal to Mullah Omar. Attempts to win over people like Mulla Wakil Ahmad Muttawwakil, Taliban’s Foreign Minister and Maulvi Jallaludin Haqqani, the unofficial Commander of the Taliban Army, have not succeeded. It is doubtful whether this group would ever defect; they would rather die with Mullah Omar and Osama bin Laden.
The second group, the madrassa-educated young Taliban fighters are completely indoctrinated. They are more or less like Mullah Omar’s human robots on an Islamic mission to fight a jihad against infidels. It is unlikely that this group would ever defect. Currently they have gone into hiding, along with their leaders, in the southern mountains.
The third and fourth group, comprising of former warlords and mujahideens, who had defected to the Taliban, are most likely to defect from the Taliban. Ideologically, they do not share the same platform as the Taliban and had no power as the Kandhahar group. Besides, they resented the Arab influence, especially that of bin Laden. This group’s loyalty, to any side, was always dubious and the West is likely to win them over, calling them “moderate” Taliban.
The last group, consisting of Arabs, led by Osama bin Laden, would never defect and fight till the end.
Given these factors, the Taliban will not lose its essential fighting machinery, despite losing territory to the
POPULAR COMMENTARIES
