Dateline Islamabad
Zarb-e-Azb: The Decisive Strike
14 Jul, 2014 · 4559
Salma Malik traces the challenges, opportunities and the way ahead for Pakistan vis-a-vis the Zarb-e-Azb operation launched against terrorists
Operation Zarb-e-Azb, launched against militants in North Waziristan
by the Pakistani military on 15 June is now entering the second phase of
clearing and reclaiming lost spaces. A few days ago, Miranshah, an important
city, was 80% reclaimed and for the first time since the launch of the
operation, the press corps was allowed a guided tour of the place. The Operation
was on the cards for a very long time and a recent interview of the previous
military spokesperson in which he hinted an intentional delay by the previous
military chief, has added to the list of controversies as to why this decision
took so long to be set into motion. The public sentiment was unanimously against
the militants and terrorists and heavily in favour of a Sri Lanka type
operation that brought down the Liberation Tigers of the Tamil Eelam, without
realising the pros and cons of the problem. Simultaneously, a faction
comprising the clergy, their supporters and empathisers as well as political
parties pitched dialogue with the angry and disgruntled brethren as a means to
appease and bring them back in the mainstream.
Though the collateral part couldn’t more be accurate, since
the 1980s Afghan war, Pakistan has undergone a drastic transformation, which
has affected the entire socio-political, economic and cultural fabric of the
society. The decision-makers of the Cold War days, judging the geopolitical
developments, made critical but misinformed decisions which served well in short
term but proved disastrous in the long term. Resultantly, two generations have
paid a heavy price for the militancy and terrorism that haunts their daily
lives. Therefore, the argument that this is not our war is as far from the
truth as the US’ initial claims of innocence over state failure in Afghanistan.
The elected leadership initially favoured and opted for an
almost unconditional dialogue with the Tehrik–i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) operating
in the concerned area alone, against stiff public uproar and opposition from
political parties and concerned quarters. In one sense, the offer and opening a
channel for dialogue was a good tactical measure; but it had two severe consequences:
the military lost precious time and the militants gained advantage and crossed
over to safer areas across border or any other place of choice, with their men
and firepower. The militants, as they gained time, took the inaction and a
general lack of consensus in the political ranks as a sign of weakness and
inflicted heavy damages which included the mass killing of 26 captured security
personnel, and mounted attacks on Karachi Airport.
Any harboured illusions have since been laid to rest and since mid-June, the
Pakistani armed forces are engaged in the military operation. With 30,000
troops committed to clear militant sanctuaries, strongholds and hideouts from
the two main areas of Miranshah and Mirali, the task at hand has been enormous.
The timing was bad, given that summer could not be more unsuitable for the
troops, compounded by the beginning of the Islamic month of Ramzan within a
fortnight of the operation.
The herculean task of evacuation and safe passage
to the local population, whose numbers according to the available data was
around 500,000 but by now the authorities have a registered a figure around
833, 274 people. Furthermore, Pakistani authorities, after repeated requests,
managed to secure the Hamid Karzai government in Kabul’s cooperation in sealing
the border – especially in Nuristan and Kunar provinces, and also disallow
sanctuaries to fleeing militants on Afghan soil; but this arrangement now
appears in jeopardy after a fatal strike from the Afghan side on a Pakistani
military patrol, claiming several lives.
The resolve with which the military is dealing this decisive
blow is evident to all, but not without skeptics and criticism. The prime criticism
is that the military strike occurred too late in the day, allowing an easy and
timely escape to the main culprits. Yet, the zero tolerance policy towards the
TTP and its local or foreign affiliates is what was long needed. In the absence
of an embedded media, the only narrative available is the military’s. In response,
the military provided a guided tour of the 80% cleared town of Miranshah to the
media. Will the military operation be sufficient in flushing out the militants
and the larger issue of terrorism? Definitely not. This is just one aspect of
the larger nationwide effort, which needs to tackle militant strongholds and
nurseries in other parts of the country; check the inflow of money and support
these actors receive from all quarters; maintain a zero tolerance approach, and
strengthen governance, law and order as well as judicial protocols in handling
such issues. This won’t be easy, given how despite a public demand for stiffer
security measures, the Protection of Pakistan ordinance (POPO) has met with
enormous criticism. To date, the authorities remain indecisive over the
placement of the National Counter-terrorism Authority.
At the moment, the greater challenge is the assistance and finally
rehabilitation and resettlement of the Internally Displaced Persons, supplemented
by developing infrastructure and self-sustaining institutional mechanisms for
the affected population. It is high time the government breaks old great game
buffer myths, abolish the British made FCR, and accord full provincial status
to the seven agencies. The success of the Operation will carry positive
dividends for both Pakistan and Afghanistan. There is a need to stand united
for a sustained, stable and peaceful future that can help assure prosperity and better regional relations.